Essential SF: A Concise Guide by Jonathan Cowie and Tony Chester
Sep 5, 20:26 by IROSF
Thread for the discussion of Essential SF
, or Greg Beatty's review.
The article is here
[ Reply ]
Have to agree with the assessment with regard to oversights. Those are some major omissions.
A work such as this should offer some critical judgement and not just the popularity contests. Award lists are fun as a takeoff for discussion but shouldn't be confused with ultimate statements of quality.
As a film critic I tell people the list of Oscar winners can be useful, but you're going to miss an awful lot of good films that way, often ones better than what actually won.
[ Edited: Nov 30, 00:00 ] [ Reply ]
Want to Post? Evil spammers have forced us to require login: